"It’s a fascinating choice who's second": Rich Eisen breaks down Browns’ quarterback battle ahead of crucial season opener

The Cleveland Browns are entering the 2025 season with a quarterback storyline that has fans and analysts on edge. Joe Flacco has been named the starter, but rookies Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders have both claimed spots on the 53-man roster. As the Browns prepare to face the Cincinnati Bengals in their season opener, one misstep from Flacco could instantly reshape the depth chart. With two talented rookies waiting in the wings, Week 1 promises high stakes and big surprises.Joe Flacco brings veteran savvy to Cleveland, yet even experienced quarterbacks aren’t immune to early-season scrutiny. The Bengals’ defense is known for forcing mistakes, and Week 1 could test Flacco’s poise immediately. Analyst Rich Eisen highlighted the fragile balance in the Browns’ QB lineup, “One Trey Hendrickson get off in Week 1 and the Browns may have either Dillon Gabriel or Shedeur Sanders as their go-forward quarterback,” Eisen said.He added context about Flacco’s strengths, “And it's not like, Flacco's a spring chicken. He is smart enough to read a defense and get rid of a football and protect himself, which is great news.”Behind Flacco, Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders have shown flashes of brilliance during training camp and preseason games. Gabriel, drafted in the third round, combines mobility and a quick release, while Sanders has impressed with poise and football IQ. Both rookies are ready to step up if given the chance.Eisen noted the intriguing decision the Browns face, “But at the end of the day of getting Flacco, acquiring Kenny Pickett, and then drafting Dillon Gabriel in the third round before Shedeur, only to take Shedeur anyway at the end of the day, it is now going to be a fascinating choice as to who is second on the depth chart for the Cleveland Browns.”The opener against Cincinnati is a proving ground. Flacco must demonstrate leadership under pressure, while Gabriel and Sanders wait for their opportunity. Coaching decisions will be closely watched, and a single misstep could dramatically shift Cleveland’s QB hierarchy.The Browns’ quarterback situation blends talent with uncertainty. Week 1 could influence not only who starts, but also the offensive approach, roster moves, and even future draft considerations. Fans will be watching closely to see which rookie emerges and whether Flacco can navigate the high-pressure start to the season.Also read: Saints shock fans with bold roster move, release 2023 second-round defensive end Isaiah Foskey as team reshapes defense